Metal Roofing Pros and Cons: Is It Right for Your Texas Home?
A metal roof usually costs more up front than asphalt shingles, but it could spare you another roof replacement if you plan to stay in your house for decades. If you’re likely to move in a few years, shingles may be the better buy.
A reflective finish can also keep the attic cooler in summer. Hail can leave dents you’ll see from the street, and some seam designs make it hard for a roofer to replace just one damaged panel.
How long does a metal roof last, and is it worth the extra cost?
The Roofing Contractors Association of Texas estimates 40 to 70 years for residential metal roofing and 20 to 30 for architectural asphalt shingles. Use those ranges for planning. The coating, installation, local weather and upkeep all affect how long your roof lasts. If a bid says “40 years,” check what’s covered. The flashing around a vent may need repair while the paint is still under warranty.
Two houses can have the same roof area, but the one with dormers and valleys takes more time to roof. Suppose the metal bid comes in $8,000 higher than the shingle bid for the same tear-off, decking allowance and flashing work.
If you sell in eight years, either roof could still have plenty of life left. Would you pay the difference to have metal while you live there? It’s hard to know whether a buyer would pay extra for it or how much you’d save on cooling. If you plan to stay 30 years, avoiding another shingle replacement may be worth more to you.
If a leak started your search, first find out whether your current roof can be repaired.
How the three metal roofing systems compare
From the curb, two gray steel roofs can look alike. One may have rows of exposed screws and washers to maintain. On the other, the fasteners sit under raised seams.
| Roof system | What you’ll see | What matters when buying |
|---|---|---|
| Standing seam | Long panels with raised seams. The main panel fasteners are hidden. | Usually costs more than exposed-fastener panels. The seam design affects future repairs. |
| Exposed-fastener panels | Rows of visible screws through the panel face. | Often the lower-cost metal option. The sealing washers stay exposed to the weather. |
| Stone-coated steel | Steel panels shaped like shingles, shakes or tile and surfaced with bonded stone granules. | Fasteners can be hidden or driven through the front edge. Confirm how this model fastens and keep its name for repairs. |
If your porch roof slopes less steeply than the main roof, ask whether the same panels can go on both. With some panels, the porch needs a separate roof system underneath to keep it dry.
DECRA’s product specifications give a standard minimum slope of three inches of rise per horizontal foot for Villa Tile and four for Shingle XD. On a porch that rises three inches per foot, the Shingle XD installation guide allows those panels only as a decorative layer over a roof system that meets local code. Ask whether that extra work is in the bid.
On a finished roof, afternoon sun can reveal shallow waves you might miss on a small panel sample. Roofers call this oil canning. A narrower flat section or small ribs can make the waves less noticeable. The Metal Construction Association shows the same roof in different light. Before you order, look at an installed roof with the sun hitting the panels at an angle.
How does metal handle Texas hail, wind and heat?
Hail dents and wind resistance
Hail can leave a dent without opening a path for water. The 2011 Dallas–Fort Worth storm investigation found no leaks on the metal roofs the team examined, even where hail left substantial dents. A later North Texas report includes a photo of the dented seam that investigators thought might have opened when the hail hit. A shallow dent between intact seams may need no repair, though you might still mind seeing it from the driveway. If a contractor recommends work after a storm, ask for a photo of the opened joint, torn metal or other damage the repair would address.
Ask your roofer, “How will you fasten these panels to my roof, and does that installation meet the wind requirements for my address?” The Texas Department of Insurance points homeowners to the manufacturer’s tested installation for the panels. Ask how your roof deck compares with the one used in the test, which fasteners the crew will use and how far apart they’ll go.
A cooler roof in summer
If your air-conditioning ducts run through a hot attic, the cooled air can warm up on its way to your rooms. A reflective finish can help keep the attic cooler, so the air in those ducts picks up less heat. You may see a smaller benefit in a well-insulated house with ducts inside the living space. Reflective asphalt shingles are an option, too. Look up the colors you like in the Cool Roof Rating Council’s product directory and compare their aged solar reflectance, the share of sunlight each surface reflects after weathering.
Salt air along the Gulf Coast
If you live near Galveston Bay, check which steel or aluminum panels and finishes are suited to salt air before settling on a color. Steel can rust at cut edges. McElroy’s Galvalume steel warranty lists different distances for breaking surf, a large bay and a marsh. It also excludes failures from edge corrosion. Give the supplier your address and ask for the written warranty for the panel you’re considering.
What upkeep and repairs should you expect?
On an exposed-fastener roof, a washer seals each hole where a panel screw passes through the steel. If the washer deteriorates or the screw backs out, rain can follow the screw through the panel.
Standing seam hides most of those screw heads. Leaves can still collect where the roof meets a chimney or on the uphill side of a skylight, trapping water there. The flashing that directs water around those openings can loosen or get damaged while the panels are still sound. Include those spots in your roof maintenance plan.
Picture a branch ruining a panel halfway across the roof. How many panels would a roofer have to remove to reach that one? McElroy’s 138T and 238T systems use a separate seam cap that lets a roofer replace one panel while its neighbors stay in place. Other interlocking designs may require the roofer to work back across adjacent panels. That’s how damage to one panel can leave you paying for labor on several.
Rain noise and rooftop solar
Will you hear the rain upstairs? Rain can drum on a metal patio cover. Over a bedroom, solid decking, insulation and a finished ceiling can muffle the sound. If you sleep under a vaulted ceiling, ask the roofer which of those layers will go above it.
Planning to add solar? Before you order the metal roofing, give your solar installer the make and model of the roof panel. Ask how they’d attach the solar rack to it. Some standing seams accept clamps that hold a rack without putting holes through the roof panels. The shape of the seam determines which clamps fit. An exposed-fastener roof calls for a different attachment. Ask both installers to confirm the matching hardware and any roof warranty conditions in writing.
How to compare metal roofing quotes
Before you compare the totals, see what each roofer has put in writing.
- Which roof am I buying? Two bids can both say “26-gauge steel” and still specify slightly different thicknesses. To compare residential metal roofing options, get the make and model of each panel. Check the manufacturer’s specifications for metal type, thickness, finish and fastening method. A color name alone won’t identify a replacement panel later.
- What work is in the price? Check tear-off and disposal, underlayment, and what happens if damaged decking turns up. Get a price per sheet or another written basis for that extra work.
- What happens where the roof changes shape? Look for the porch transition, valleys where two slopes meet, and flashing around chimneys or skylights. A bid that leaves one of those out can look cheaper on paper.
- What upkeep am I agreeing to? Get the panel’s care schedule and a contact for repairs. If the fasteners are exposed, find out who checks the screws and washers, which visits are included and what an extra visit costs.
- If my roof leaks around a vent, who do I call, and who pays for the repair? Ask which written warranty, if any, covers the repair and the labor. Read the installer’s workmanship terms alongside the manufacturer’s coverage for fading, peeling or corrosion, and check what transfers if you sell. McElroy, for example, excludes roof openings from its standard weathertightness coverage and offers a separate rider.
If only one bid includes new porch flashing, ask the other roofer to price it. If neither roofer knows how much decking needs replacing until the old roof comes off, compare what each charges per sheet.
Considering a metal roof for your home?
Tell us a little about your current roof. We’ll help you compare what metal and asphalt shingles would cost up front and how much upkeep each would need.
